Angel Soft 18 Mega Rolls Are $12.77 Live and Beat the $14.97 Charmin Ultra Soft 12-Pack Per Sheet
Live Amazon.com prices to Chicago 60601: Angel Soft's 18 Mega Rolls (5,760 two-ply sheets) cost $12.77, about $2.22 per 1,000 sheets. Charmin Ultra Soft's 12 Mega Rolls (2,496 sheets) cost $14.97, about $6.00 per 1,000. Angel Soft is my value pick. Our Angel Soft catalog card ($5.68) is stale.
Affiliate disclosure: The Deals Home is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. I may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: The Angel Soft 18 Mega Roll pack is $12.77 live to Chicago ZIP 60601 for 5,760 two-ply sheets, about $2.22 per 1,000 sheets. The Charmin Ultra Soft 12 Mega Roll pack is $14.97 for 2,496 two-ply sheets, about $6.00 per 1,000 sheets. Charmin costs only $2.20 more at the register, but you pay roughly 2.7 times as much per sheet. For a budget household, I'd buy Angel Soft.
I cover value from Chicago. I'm not measuring softness with a machine or counting how many sheets a person uses. I'm asking one budget question: which 2-ply pack gives you more paper per dollar when both are sold and shipped by Amazon today?
What it is
The Angel Soft pack is 18 Mega Rolls that Angel Soft labels as equal to 72 regular rolls. The listing says each roll has 320 two-ply sheets, for a sheet count of 5,760. It's marked septic safe and flushable. Live buy box: $12.77. That works out to about 71¢ per Mega Roll. Our catalog card still says $5.68, which is stale. Sold by Amazon.com, ships from Amazon.com, in stock. Rating: 4.8 from about 110,500 ratings.
The Charmin Ultra Soft pack is 12 Mega Rolls that Charmin labels as equal to 48 regular rolls. Amazon's spec table lists 208 sheets per roll and a net count of 2,496 two-ply sheets. It's also marked septic safe and clog free. Live: $14.97, about $1.25 per Mega Roll. Our catalog card matches at $14.97. Sold and shipped by Amazon.com, in stock. Rating: 4.8 from about 47,400 ratings.
Who it's for
Buy Angel Soft at $12.77 if you are stocking a shared apartment, a family bathroom, or a guest bath and you want the most paper for the money. To get the same 5,760 sheets from Charmin, you'd need about 2.3 packs, roughly $34.55 at today's price. That's about $21.80 more for the same sheet count. Eighteen rolls also means fewer reorders. I like that in a Chicago winter, when I don't want to haul a bulky box home through the snow.
Buy Charmin Ultra Soft at $14.97 if softness is the whole point for you and you're fine paying for it. Charmin's pitch is a plusher sheet, and that's a real preference, not a mistake. Just know you're buying comfort and not value. Each roll also runs out sooner, since it has 208 sheets against Angel Soft's 320.
Who should skip
Skip the 18-roll Angel Soft box if you have very little storage. Eighteen Mega Rolls take up a lot of closet space in a small city apartment. Skip Charmin if you're buying on price, because nothing on this page makes it the cheaper roll. Skip any marketplace seller that isn't Amazon.com unless you meant to buy from them. Both buy boxes are Amazon today, and toilet paper from third-party sellers often costs a lot more.
Honest nits
- "Mega Roll" is not a standard size. Angel Soft says one Mega equals 4 regular rolls, and Charmin says the same. But their Megas have 320 and 208 sheets. Compare sheets, not roll counts.
- I'm comparing sheet counts, not sheet size or thickness. Charmin may use a bigger or plusher sheet. I haven't measured one, so my per-1,000-sheet math is about count only.
- Our Angel Soft card is stale. It says $5.68. Live is $12.77. I'm quoting the Chicago 60601 buy box only.
- Charmin's page lists other sizes. The same listing also offers Super Mega and other variants with different sheet counts. Make sure your cart shows 12 Mega Rolls before you compare it to these numbers.
- The "= 72 regular rolls" line is marketing. Even on that scale Angel Soft still wins, at about 18¢ per "regular roll" against Charmin's 31¢.
Value verdict
Buy Angel Soft at $12.77 for about $2.22 per 1,000 two-ply sheets and the most paper per box. Buy Charmin Ultra Soft at $14.97 only if a softer sheet matters more to you than the price. Don't judge Angel Soft by our $5.68 card today.
Is Charmin worth paying about 2.7 times more per sheet? For a value shopper, no.
Compare
Live Amazon buy-box prices for Chicago ZIP 60601, October 27, 2026: compare Angel Soft and Charmin Ultra Soft toilet paper.
Live prices checked on Amazon for delivery to Chicago 60601 on October 27, 2026. Our Angel Soft catalog card showed $5.68 and was stale. The Charmin card matched at $14.97. Confirm the live Amazon seller and pack size before you buy.
Products in This Review
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more
Angel Soft Toilet Paper, 18 Mega Rolls = 72 Regular Rolls, Soft and Strong
Angel Soft® Mega Rolls are designed to last you longer, with rolls that are 4 times as big as our regular rolls. Plus, with 320 2-ply sheets on every Mega Roll, you’ll always have plenty of the softness and strength you love on hand. And like all your favorite Angel Soft® products, our Mega Toilet Paper Rolls are flushable and septic safe in well-maintained sewer and septic systems. Angel Soft® Toilet Paper. Soft and Strong. Simple.
Charmin Toilet Paper Ultra Soft, 12 Mega Rolls = 48 Regular Rolls, 2-ply Bath Tissue
Get irresistible softness with Charmin Ultra Soft Smooth Tear™ toilet paper. Every roll is crafted with wavy edges that tear so much better vs. the leading USA 1-ply bargain brand, so you can have a smooth, more enjoyable go. And each sheet of Charmin Ultra Soft Smooth Tear toilet paper is 2X more absorbent vs. the leading USA 1-ply bargain brand, so you can use less! We made it MEGA in size, so you get MEGA value. 1 Charmin Ultra Soft Mega Roll equals 4 Regular Rolls, so you can change the roll less often based on the number of sheets in Charmin Regular Roll. Want to save even more time by running back to the store less? Stock up on Charmin toilet paper with our larger count packs! Charmin Ultra Soft Smooth Tear™ is also 2-ply and designed to be clog-safe and septic-safe. We all go, why not Enjoy The Go with America’s favorite toilet paper, based on Total Charmin Brand Sales (Nielsen 2024 Dollar Sales)